I believe that underlying my every inquiry ever, I am fundamentally asking:
What should I do?
In small contexts, this can be simple, clear, even comforting: a board game, a conversation, someone saying “thank you.” But gaze too long at any context and its meaning can begin to fall away inside a sufficiently larger context: the universe, infinite time, mortality, death.
As a kid waking up and wondering what on earth I was alive for, what the point was, what I should be doing, I eventually found myself introspectively searching the largest contexts for some anchor of meaning or ought.
I decided that since I was mortal, my own satisfaction was irrelevant, and the best I could do was forward value as far and wide into the future as possible: give to sentience in the greatest possible way.
But that was a stop-gap jump to a culturally acceptable conclusion, not a truth built on my truest understanding of reality.
It took decades for me to stop beating the dead horse of objective meaninglessness.
In 2010, at age 24, I begrudgingly accepted my mere mortal subjective experience as a necessary place to seek meaning. I could not run myself on objectivity. My body needs calories. My lower psychic self needs to feel like there is something in it for itself.
This was acquiescence to the manifest: a weakness of my being, not an objective truth.
Fast forward through meditation, somatic awakening, extreme relationships, community leadership, leaving the West Coast, and becoming boring again. I am coming to a new synthesis. It could sound delusional or arrogant, but the wiser parts of myself do not really have many spiritual questions anymore. It is only my lesser egoic parts that clamor and complain against the reality apparent.
I am multitudes: the wise, and the many selfishly ignorant.
It is not that objectivity provides no meaning. It is that, even if it did not, this would be insufficient for beings such as ourselves. We exist as subjective beings. Fortunately, we have meaning baked into every valence, every quality of experience.
Our minds can be clean and curious and attempt to build more accurate models of understanding and prediction. And I believe the deepest part of us has the opportunity to mature in our volitional relationship to our valenced experience and our reality model.
This, to me, is the most meaningful trinity of lived reality:
- experiential valence
- predictive modeling
- volitional maturity
Or, in the shortest form:
Reality, Goodness, Work.
But as we know from discussion, a lot can be lost in translation.
Shorthands are good anchors, weak guides.
